Question:
Does anyone know why Bu$h wants more illegal immigrants not less?
jl_jack09
2006-03-31 05:46:26 UTC
A full 74 percent of Repubs. do not agree with Bu$h. That was especially the case on immigration, with Bush and Fox clearly trying to sway a divided Congress to create a program to allow illegal immigrants — an estimated 6 million of them from Mexico — to work temporarily in the United States in low-paying jobs.

The Senate this week is debating an immigration bill that includes a guest worker program. The version that passed the Republican-controlled House late last year took a get-tough approach — calling for more fences along the border and tougher penalties for those who sneak across — and did not create the guest worker program that Bush wants.

But Bush said he's optimistic that disagreements on Capitol Hill can be worked out.

"I told the president that I am committed to having a comprehensive immigration bill on my desk," Bush said. "And by comprehensive, I mean not only border security — a bill that has border security in it, a
Five answers:
everything's eventual
2006-03-31 15:13:37 UTC
Hi Jack....Cheap labor=more money in G.W's own pocket....Who else is he going to get to run his ranch while he is busy screwing up the rest of the world!!! By the way did you just DIE when Bush said that he "never wanted to go to war" ...I mean how many times did he tell us that he was a "War president"????
stupidity_of_pride
2006-03-31 06:18:25 UTC
Any question asked about “our” president is difficult to answer. I am often confused by his motivations, they are not always clear. We have seen in the past that the Republican Party is trying to break out of its “old school” model and appeal to minorities. Latin Americans are being heavily courted by the right wing because they share many traditional values that the “right” professes (e.g. religious values, family values, work ethic, etc.) This may have something to do with Bush’s immigration agenda.



Also there exist a reality; we need Latin American’s to work our farmland, dishwashers, cleaning services, etc. The only other way we would be able to harvest our crops is if we forced people to do it. Remember we got rid of institutional slavery in the US two years after the end of the Civil War, but our need for cheap labor continued. That’s why our industrial base has almost completely disappeared to overseas.



And that opens up another point. Most American citizens aren’t willing to work for low wages, at least not enough of us to keep the labor market healthy. Factories need low paid, half educated folk to run the machine. The country needs a higher unemployment rate and lower wages, so we can be competitive in the world market. Be ready for some bleak days in the future, and it won’t be the fault of the Latin American.



There is also the security issue. The old model is that they sneak across for farm work, etc. and than go back when they get caught, or feel like going back. But since 9-11 and the new American paranoia, we want to make this thing more legit so we can scan who comes over and for how long.



For me, a third of the US was stolen from them anyway, and in general I like Latin Americans. They are hard working and good spirited. And they love and take care of their families despite overwhelming odds. I am passive on this issue, watching with wide eyes and folded arms.
chatsplas
2006-03-31 12:16:17 UTC
Because he's stupidly stubborn--having said he was for it, he'll stick it, just like getting us in Iraq, and staying even when it became clear to the public (he probably already knew, or should have) there were NO WMD, and NO connection to Al Qaeda. Also it's important constituency for Texas and Florida, key Bush states. It's an issue resonating within Hispanic community and vote maker or breaker in most large metropolitan centers.
Anonymous
2006-03-31 09:42:57 UTC
Your question is flawed: Bush doesn't want more illegal immigrants, he wants less illegal immigrants just like everyone else. There's two ways to do this: make it harder to get into this country, or make it easier to become a legal immigrant. Bush favors the latter, as do I.



Essentially, Bush wants to ease immigration laws to make it easier for immigrants to immigrate legally. This country was built on the very premise of being a haven of freedom to those who have been oppressed or downtrodden by poverty. "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore." When our immigration laws are so strict that hardly anyone can get into the country, a country built SOLELY to offer a haven to EXACTLY those people, well, what kind of country are we?



We claim to be a haven of freedom and democracy for the world, yet those who oppose relaxing immigration laws are essentially saying we should horde these blessings for ourselves and completely neglect the very premise tht this country was founded upon.



Don't get me wrong, I know open borders would be fodder for terrorists: you can tighten border security and still relax immigration laws.
Dwain
2006-03-31 05:52:08 UTC
The President doesn't want to do anything which could hurt his core constituency of business owners. These business people are dependent on a supply of cheap and desperate labor


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...